"The Sky is
A review by Jenni:
What I love about this
First, it's about Halloween! And unlike Andrew, I *love*
Halloween. So I've always been partial to Halloween-set episodes
of TV shows. I'm actually using this one as reward for finishing
my Halloween decorating in one evening!
I loved that the "big boys don't cry" theme came full circle. I
am adamantly against the axiom and bristle when the dad says it to
young Leonard. Then Leonard repeats it to his older
brother. It's a bad cycle and one that I know very much
exists. What I thought was so great is that Leonard learns that's
not true first from Penny and then gets it reiterated by Monica.
The fact that we then see images of both Leonard and Andrew crying
really pulls it together: big boys do cry. And that's okay and
Big fan of Dottie. I love it when another angel stands up to
Tess. I do love Tess. But
sometimes she takes that indignation and anger thing WAY too far.
She definitely did with poor neophyte Monica. Dottie calls her on
it right away and actually gets through to Tess. It's awesome to
behold! Dottie gets through to Tess enough that she actually
admits to Monica that she was wrong. Good work, Dottie!
A lot of things I appreciated most in this episode were just lil
one-liners. When Penny talks about how she still talks to her
deceased father and called it prayer, my heart leapt. That's how
I feel and so often people seem to construe that as some sort of
deification of our loved ones. That's not it at all. I only
believe in one God but I think I can still talk to many, many people in
Heaven. So good on TBAA for stressing what I think is a very
I just may shock you all but... I thought Monica was cute in
this. I felt bad for her, too. But the scene of her talking
to the cow was pretty darn adorable. And how can I, as a pet
owner, not love that she assures the cow that God loves it and will
help it? I never expect TBAA to perfectly line up with my
theology and spirituality but I do love it when it does. And here
we have it affirming after-death communication and God's love for His
Another line I loved also came from Monica. I don't read much
sci-fi cause it freaks me out. But when Monica assures Leonard
that if Martians existed they'd be loved by God and created as we were
it makes that whole genre much less scary to me. She's got a
point, after all.
For some reason I really like this line from Tess, too: "The story
isn't over til it says 'The End.'" Not sure why.
Another one was this from Monica: "Sometimes all an angel can do is
cry." I hope Andrew heard that. I think remembering that
might help him get past his "I wish I could have done more"
thoughts. I'm not sure he realizes how meaningful and ultimately
healing shared grief and sorrow can be and if that's all he has to
offer sometimes then it's enough.
Finally, the love story aspect of this episode really got to me
tonight. I have never cried over this episode but tonight I
did. I think, cynic though I sometimes am, the idea of childhood
sweethearts marrying and enjoying a near half century marriage is very
appealing. I got really invested in Leonard and Penny's
story. The scene where Monica and Penny briefly meet in the woods
was where I started to tear up. It was sort of like God was
passing Leonard's well-being off to his future wife. Even though
I knew it was coming I choked up when it was revealed that Leonard's
beloved wife was Penny. Just the way he looks at the photo is so
moving. And when Monica reminds him of the pact he and Penny made
and gives him the ring... time for a Kleenex cause all I could think
about was this juxtaposition of a young Penny holding Leonard as he
wept with Monica now doing the same in Penny's absence.
What I didn't love about this
I both love and dislike Andrew's
poutiness about Halloween. Don't get me wrong, he's so cute when
he pouts! But I'm just not sure I follow his argument that
Halloween gives death a bad reputation. For one, he's an
angel. So why isn't he taking comfort from all the kids, like
Penny and Amy, who dress as angels? Why is he relating to the
death part of "angel of death" over the angel part? Why choose to
be insulted about the reapers and not also choose to be uplifted by the
angels? Second, I'm not quite buying that Halloween makes death
look evil or gruesome or like a horror show. I think that's
intellectualizing things a bit more than most kids do. A kid in a
Grim Reaper costume just wants to be scary and get candy. I
highly doubt most of them actually think some black-cloaked monster
with a sickle is waiting for them to die. Maybe I'm wrong.
But if he's that concerned about competing with the Halloween
propaganda let me assure him that if Halloween and him competed for my
affection... he would win. ;-) I'm not complaining, though,
cause JABB has gotten so much mileage out of his hatred of Halloween!
As alluded to before, I thought Tess was just plain too angry with
Monica. "Don't tell me God sent you" was an especially low blow,
in my opinion. Who else would have?!? Maybe Monica wasn't
terribly graceful with her entrance in the church but it's not like she
I'd like to know what the reaper kid's parents' thoughts were when the
guy that answered the door didn't just give the kid candy but said he
wanted a "little chat." I love Andrew to pieces (strange phrase,
btw) but it's a little odd. I mean they don't know he's an
angel. Maybe they weren't around.
Odd or not from a stranger's perspective, as an Andrew fan I wanna
know... what did Andrew say to that kid?! Why couldn't we see
This episode made me wonder if there were actually any injuries or
fatalities related to the broadcast of "War of the Worlds."
What's this roll call Tess speaks of to Dottie? And how long does
that last cause there must be gobs and gobs and gobs, etc. of
angels? But I spose when one has an eternity it doesn't much
come Dottie could have Lifesavers yet when Tess is going through
candy at the beginning none of it's brand name? It's all
ridiculously made-up stuff. Maybe Lifesavers were
sponsors. Or was Tess making those names up?
This is gonna sound weird but... was John Dye actually driving/fake
driving during his entire flashback scene? I just ask cause at
point you see the driver's chin and cheek only and his cheek looks more
sunken than I've ever seen his to look.
At first I wondered why Andrew just let Leonard run out of the car and
see his father's dead body. Andrew stopped the kid in "Til Death
Do Us Part" from witnessing his father's death scene. I
understand Andrew couldn't drive another route but just sitting in the
car as the kid fled seemed odd. However, I'm now thinking it was
cause God's plan was for Penny and not Andrew to comfort Leonard.
Does anyone know if the girl who plays Amy, Leonard's granddaughter,
also played Emily in "Operation Smile"?
Parts that made me feel
This episode has some of my favorite Andrew shots. I've
been partial to the head shots from the driving scene. He just
looks so... perfectly Andrew.
I also feel a bit swoony at the end when he's teared up. He just
looks so compassionate and... flannel-y.
And the thought may have crossed my mind that sitting on the arm of
that chair he was
pouting in might be a good idea... He needed someone
to cheer him up. Ahem.
This episode, with the apocalyptic freaking out, was kinda weird to
watch while some people are bugging out over that Big Bang machine
those physicists are working with.
I loved the parents dancing. Makes me wish my parents had been
like that but then maybe it's kinda awkward if it's your own parents
dancing about your house.
I got to thinking about how "War of the Worlds" would never work
today. Like that lady crying about New York being
destroyed. Nowadays someone in NY would just hop online or text
or something and tell everyone it's baloney. I'm kinda surprised
it worked at all even back then since there were phones.
to the Episode Guide
(The photographs used on this
page are from "Touched by an Angel" and
owned by CBS Productions, Caroline Productions, and Moon Water
Productions. They are not being used to seek profit.)