A review by Jenni:

I watched this and "Written in Dust" on the same day, this in the morning and "Written" in the evening, and noted some parallels.  So this review contains references to "Written."

What I love about this episode:

I really like the phenomenon of creative sentencing.  And this episode gives a perfect example of it: don't punish a slumlord with a fine or a few days in the slammer.  Send him to live in his own slum!  It's perfect justice!  And in the episode it's better still since the idea comes from a child.  I love that whole "and a child shall lead them" theme.

I like that this episode comes down hard against making excusing for one's own bad behavior.  Jake tries to defend himself by references his (as he tells it) tough childhood.  But Monica, Tess, etc. won't have it.  That's great!  Sometimes the lack of accountability people have these days frightens me.  And too often other people let em get away with this sorta irresponsibility.  But it ain't happening in this episode!

Saul's prayer heard through out is really haunting.  I love it.  It obviously has a lot of impact on Jake but I also think it was symbolic of how we're all haunted by our pasts and the loved ones who have gone before us.  And just as Jake attempts to drawn out his father's voice, so sometimes do we try to drown out the memories that haunt us.

I really like that Andrew appears to Jake as an answer to Saul's prayer.  The idea that God would still have that prayer in mind, decades later, it's not surprising but it's nice to have reiterated.  Especially by Andrew. 

I love how this episode builds up a parallel between Jake and Tyler.  First, they both have ill fathers (Jake eventually loses his).  They're both financially enterprising, they go to the roof to dream of getting away with their families.  Jake even says Tyler reminds him of himself.  I think these two characters stand in for wider similarities between two communities.  This theme of shared culture shows up in "Written in Dust," too.  While there it was mostly Jewish people and Native Americans, here it's Jewish people and African Americans. 

Along those same lines, earlier in the episode Saul chastises Jake for using a derogatory name towards black kids.  He then reminds him that "we're all brothers."  Tess later drives this point home by singing "Go Down, Moses," an African American spiritual with roots in the Hebrew Scriptures.  It demonstrates that for over 100 years these two groups have shared something.  It's one of my favorite TBAA music moments.  When Jake interjects "Eliyahu" into the song it's even more poignant.  And *then* all the people join in.  Music and prayer unites them.  It's just... goosebumps.

This episode has some wonderfully dramatic shots through out!  I can't even list them all but pretty much all of Andrew's and the shot of Tess singing on the staircase and the pinpoint of light through the door after Michael is shot... wow.  They give me goosebumps at those moments, too.

Like "Written in Dust," this episode seems to have more dramatic music than usual and it really stood out for me. 

What I didn't love about this episode:
I'm a lil creeped by Tess informing Monica that God has a special kind of Passover planned for Jake.  It kinda makes it sound like Michael getting shot was part of the Divine Plan.  I prefer TBAA when it says that violence and hate are not God's doing but He can bring good outta both.  Now, maybe that's not what Tess meant.  Maybe Jake simply being at the slum during Passover was what was originally going to make it special.  But once the idea crept in my mind... it makes me wonder.  Monica does later say that hate is the reason Michael was shot so maybe that wasn't part of the original plan. 

Lingering questions:
Where did Jake's sisters go?  There are two at the table in the flashback scene yet neither appear to be at Elaine's Passover dinner with Michael and Lisa.  Maybe they moved?

Parts that made me feel swoony:
Andrew looks so regal when Jake first sees him in the apartment where Saul died.  I don't quite know why but... wow.

When Andrew tells Jake about how Elaine always thinks of Saul when she sees a Sabbath candle, for some reason that gets me.  And maybe God just told Andrew to say that but I kinda get the feeling Andrew knew.  Like he still keeps tabs on his assignments and their families even decades later.  I love that idea and it seems like him.  Just watch "Sign of the Dove."

I have a thing for guys in long coats.  Andrew has a long coat in this.  I already have a thing for Andrew.  So Andrew in a long coat...  Then turn it into Andrew, in a long coat, having Jake flee from him...  Obviously I feel terrible for Jake weeping over Michael.  But how terrible for Andrew to have someone flee him as if Andrew himself wanted to kill Michael!  So... Andrew, in a long coat, being mistaken for something evil, and having a human (who he loves cause he's an angel and that's what they do) flee him... what about that doesn't make me want to throw myself at him?

And when he looks kinda shadowy on the street and like he'd really rather not be there...  Green Day's "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" starts running through my head.  Then I feel worse for Andrew who maybe does "walk a lonely road."  And then at the end... he walks alone into the dark night...  MAJOR concussion moment cause I really do want to jump into the TV and run after him and walk with him.

On a happier note, I'm so relieved for everyone involved (including Andrew) when he walks away from the door Jake and Michael were behind.  And Andrew's small smile suggests he's relieved, too.  Which just makes me feel even more for him.

Random thoughts:
I wish I'd been exposed to different religions more as a child.  I think it woulda been great to have taken part in a Passover seder as the lil boy Jake's mom invites over gets to.  The more we learn about others' beliefs and rituals, the more we love and respect them, I believe.

The angel of death actually does not appear in any of the Exodus accounts in my Bibles.  I've got "angel of the Lord" and "avenging angel," I believe is how it's worded.  But no AODs.  A theology professor once told me that's a translation issue and
"angel of death" really isn't very accurate.  I found that interesting since, prior to TBAA, my main exposure to the idea of AODs was through "The Ten Commandments."  Now I find out that maybe wasn't even sposed to be an AOD!

 While I appreciate Elaine assuring the little boy that the Passover story is about God providing for His people, I still find it chilling from certain perspectives.  Isn't it in Prince of Egypt where they have the shot of a lil Egyptian kid and then you just see their hand fall... dead?  What did a lil Egyptian toddler do to deserve the wrath of God?  It makes me think of the Kevin Smith movie Dogma.  A character in that, Loki, is revealed to be the angel who slaughtered the firstborn.  Directly afterwards, he and a friend fall.  Loki and his buddy do some terrible things in the movie but that bit really upset me and made me feel for them.  Imagine being sent to end the lives of children just cause they were born to Egyptian parents! 

As a Christian, most of my associations with Passover (at least prior to college) came from the gospel accounts of the Passion.  It's typically thought that Jesus was crucified around Passover.  So in my belief system, Passover is the setting to one of the most dramatic stories of a Father and a Son, culminating in the violent death and resurrection of the innocent Son.  Watching this episode with the focus on Saul's and Jake's relationship and Jake's and Michael's, I just automatically think of that other relationship.  It just makes the episode more dramatic, disturbing, and inspiring for me.

Back to the Episode Guide

(The photographs used on this page are from "Touched by an Angel" and owned by CBS Productions, Caroline Productions, and Moon Water Productions. They are not being used to seek profit.)