A review by Jenni:
Yay! Thanks to the four day weekend, I watched this on my
What I love about this episode:
I think this is a really great, profound quote from Sam at the
beginning: "When children stop asking questions, that's when you
have a problem." As a former daycare assistant, I know how
grating constant questions can be. But he's right. If
kids lose their curiosity and wonder we're all in deep trouble.
As for Sam, I just really like him in this episode. I like
that he provides continuity between the present scenes and the
past scenes. Plus, it's nice to see Tess be assured by a
higher up since she's usually got that role. Hierarchies can
be bad sometimes but they can also be comforting.
I also like Sam a lot as Andrew's supervisor. But it makes
me wish we coulda seen more of the two of them working
together. We get a bit of it in "Labor of Love" and "The
Journalist" but not too much elsewhere. I mean I know
they're in other episodes together but they don't interact as
I love all the costumes. It would be so much fun to pick
costumes for something like this! Okay, probly
stressful. But fun!
As someone with what I hope is a healthy respect for dreams, I
like that Monica assures Lincoln that sometimes dreams come from
God. Personally, I wouldn't have had her mention leaders
specifically as I believe God speaks to us all and may sometimes
use dreams to do so. Nonetheless, I like that scene between
Monica and Lincoln a lot.
Still keeping with that scene, I'm really taken with the part
where Lincoln shows Monica his pile of death threats and his hat
with the bullet hole. He's so calm. It makes a person
realize how, despite what personal feelings may be about a
president, they and their families take on a huge load of fears
when they step into that office. So I have to respect and
even be moved by that.
Later in the scene, Monica's speech about how
people will walk the White House halls and listen for the echo of
Lincoln's footsteps also gets to me. How true that is!
Lincoln continues to have so many people in thrall. When she
talks about principles v. politics, though, I can't help but shake
the feeling that this episode was written by folks more than a lil
bothered by certain Clintonian antics. Or maybe that's just
me at 16 chiming in cause I was that bothered person.
Now onto Tess. Her statement that "a real man lost his life,
he shed real blood, and his child went to bed that night crying
because his daddy was not coming home" really gets to the heart of
history. I think we have a way of losing humanity in the
face of historical events. We consider what Lincoln's death
meant to the country as a whole but maybe not so much what
Lincoln's death meant to those who knew and loved him. This
is probly healthy. If we considered the grief behind every
historical event, we'd never be happy. But it is good to, on
occasion, consider the real and direct loss experienced by our
ancestors. Tess' words also call to mind a TV movie I used
to really like called "Tad." It was about Lincoln's son and
I wish it were available to buy. I remember being very moved
On a general note, I love how evenly this episode is divided among
the angels. And without compromising the existing time
line! Andrew and Monica both play important roles in 1865
yet don't inexplicably meet for the third time for the first time
or however that works in some episodes (I'm looking at you,
It moves me to hear Sam tell Andrew that the loss of life in the
Civil War broke God's heart. Then when he follows it with
the statement that God could lift weapons out of every hand but
then there would be no freedom... honestly, I think this is one of
the better written episodes. Cause that's really something
to think about.
I think this episode is also a great example of how off-screen
violence can often be more emotionally effective than on-screen
violence. We never see Lincoln get shot. We never see
Lincoln in the theatre at all. But there's something
suffocating and desperate about watching Andrew just waiting and
straining to hear. Then the horror that sets in when he
hears the gun and jolts away. There's no need to show
My gosh. This episode is just packed with emotional moments
for me. The transition of Tess and Calvin at the Lincoln
memorial to the funeral with Monica brushing away that soldier's
tear... goosebumps every time. I remember the first time I
ever saw this just being a wreck.
My favorite quote from this episode wasn't written for it at all
but is this one from President Lincoln himself: "We are not
enemies, but friends. We must not be enemies. Though
passion may have strained, it must not break our bonds of
affection. The mystic cords of memory will swell when again
touched as surely they will be by the better angels of our
I like that Tess stresses that JWB *chose* Hell. I'm kinda
bothered by TBAA determining the fate of a real person just as I'm
often irked by the assumption that Judas definitely went to
Hell. None of us know what happened in their final
moments. Nonetheless, I do believe some people choose
Hell. God doesn't send them: they do. So it was
comforting to me to see TBAA back me up on what, at least
sometimes, seems like a minority position.
Finally, I love that Tess names Lincoln AND Calvin's mom as
heroes. Because heroic deeds happen every day and are
committed by people in all walks of life.
What I didn't love about
My gripe with Hallmark for cutting scenes remains. But at
least this time they refrained from cutting an important Andrew
scene. Granted, I may have just not realized something was
missing. But all I noticed was that they cut the scene of
Monica and Mrs. Lincoln working on the dress and a couple seconds
of Andrew approaching JWB while he's holed up in that tree.
Instead, they start that scene with Andrew there which seems
abruptly edited but at least doesn't leave out anything of massive
plot or character important. We all know Andrew can walk so
I guess it's not vital to see it.
Secretary Stanton's beard... not so great.
So... I've been reading the Bible more lately. Trying to,
anyhow. And while I'm glad that Andrew says slavery is an
abomination (I very much agree, of course), I'm afraid I think his
response to its place in the Bible is just a lil too clean and
nice. Frankly, the Bible disturbs me as concerns
slavery. I suppose it is just acknowledging it exists but
God seems a lil too cozy with the situation. I mean if He
can guide Abraham and Co. to travel from land to land, why can't
He also tell them to free their slaves? Or at the very least
not abuse them like Sarai does. I can't honestly think of a
way TBAA could address this easily so I'm not majorly
bothered. But if I were JWB, I really can't see Andrew's
response carrying much weight with me.
This is also something that's not a complaint about the episode so
much as how things are in reality. When JWB shouts the N
word after Sam has entered... that's a tough scene to watch.
As much as I love Andrew and would hate for him to get in
trouble... some part of my wishes he's socked JWB hard right
I remain disturbed by seeing Andrew back lit by fire. It
makes me think bad, terrifying things.
Watching this episode on its own, I'm very glad Sam proclaims
Andrew's promotion. But when I think of the finale where we
have God telling Monica the news... it annoys me. Sometimes
I really get the feeling from TBAA that God loves Monica best and
that is NOT good.
Ya know... I gotta wonder about the fall out of Tess
telling that story. What did the kids think about a sub
talking about angels? What did their parents think? Or
maybe Tess kept the angel angle to herself?
So how did Andrew get his accent? He obviously pre-existed
the States so did he have a prescient accent or did he only
develop it later on? Then how did he lose it? Cause it
barely registers later on.
I may just be making this up and sometime when I'm bored I'll look
into this but wasn't there a mysterious third man that really was
spotted with JWB? And, to date, no one's entirely sure about
who that guy was. If it is true, I think the TBAA writers
came up with a pretty interesting explanation. It's also
apropos as that would make Andrew exactly what JWB said he was: an
interloper, a mysterious stranger who thickens the plot.
I can remember after this first aired many people had the same
question: where was Abraham Lincoln during the several days
between his own death and JWB's when he *finally* went Home???
that made me feel swoony:
Okay, I'm not recommending that Andrew wear those sideburns in
this day and age but... he looks way cute in this! Not just
the sideburns but also the hat and the lovely clothes. Brown
looks great on him. And since I'm a big fan of him layering
clothing... this is just awesome.
I'm impressed that, in what we can guess has been a lengthy
career, Andrew hadn't failed until 1865! Wow! And I
love the way he makes this known. In a sorta prideful but
not egomaniacal "surely not me!" way. It's cute. Yet,
The lil curl on Andrew's forehead... It's adorable.
Andrew's answers to JWB are great. First, I love that he
says he's from the "state of grace." And then insisting that
he comes from the best stock. He ain't joking! And I'm
goofy cause I just really like that Andrew requests
sarsaparilla. It also makes me nostalgic for a restaurant we
had that closed well over a decade ago but that served
sarsaparilla in brown glass bottles with cowboys on them.
I have no idea what Andrew had in mind but his barely formed plot
to stop JWB "some other way" intrigues me. And makes me like
him just a lil bit more. I'm not sure why. I think
it's calling to mind "Pandora's Box" or something when Andrew gets
aggressive which, on occasion, I felt was good to see.
Andrew's facial expressions as he gives JWB the whole revelation
scene are pretty vivid and passionate. Actually,
compassionate and passionate may just be the most accurate words
for Andrew. And lovely.
And then there's this expression... It kills me when
Andrew's speaking to the dying JWB and he starts to smile with
hope that maybe he'll get through to him... then watching it fade
when Booth dies. Then watching Andrew, seemingly
shell-shocked, walk away...
Honestly, I just love Andrew in this episode. His smile when
he gets promoted and then approaches Lincoln... how do people not
get why I'm still obsessing over this guy???
When they show the kid's
projects, I couldn't help but wonder what TBAA staffers got to
have all that fun drawing those. Or maybe they had their
kids do em.
Thanks to one of my TBAA news alerts, I learned that David Selby
(who plays Lincoln here) participated in a Lincoln tribute this
year. That's pretty cool.
Andrew tells Sam he keeps his pocket watch set five minutes
fast. Just saying cause that could be a good trivia
question. Actually, I may have already used that.
How astounding to think that back then a bodyguard would leave the
president's side and sit in a pub!
If I ever write a Dyeland story set in the future (like maybe the
finale) I want to remember to make mention of President
Calvin. That would be pretty darn cool.
Scenes Hallmark cut:
-Hallmark completely cuts a scene of Monica talking to a worried
Mary Todd while working on her dress.
-Hallmark also cuts the scene of JWB journaling and talking to
Davey or whatever his name was before Andrew arrives at the tree
moments before they hear the cavalry. The Hallmark version
starts the scene with Andrew arriving. So ya don't get the
full grasp of how freaking delusional JWB and the kid were.
Further on down the road...
I feel like I actually pay attention better when I watch on my
computer. So I'm going back to that. Maybe at least
until I get to the spot where I took down quotes. Not sure
when that started but I think pausing to type those out is a lot
of the issue. It's just so much easier when I'm both
watching and typing on the puter. Anyhow... I'm also
giving up on just watching one a week and updating the Photo
Gallery accordingly. From here on out I'm watching as many
episodes as I want and the PG will just have to wait til I want to
work on it. I love having the photos but it just takes so
long to update and was starting to take away from my enjoyment of
the show as I tried to cram time in for the photos.
Was Sam the only angel to wear a bow-tie? Just curious.
Gah... John is cute as a button in this episode. And
"It's amazing what peace can do to people's spirits." Never
really zeroed in on that quote from Andrew but it's nice.
"Angels do fail. And humans fail but God does not
fail." That one's spoken by Sam.
Such a lovely accent...
Gah. Stanton's beard *is* truly horrendous. I just
wanna yank it off.
It is a shame THC cut the dress scene. It does really
humanize the Lincolns. Hopefully GMC will re-insert some of
THC's cuts... and not make tons of their own.
I still love those lil curls on his forehead...
later the hatred in a man's heart finds its way into his words and
into his hands til he finally becomes the creator of evil
itself." Per Sam. So don't let hatred into your heart,
I wonder if David Selby kept the photo of him as Lincoln?
The "first post-war smile" one. It'd be a cool prop to have
as an actor, I think.
There are still parts of this episode that give me chills.
The first comes during Monica's "listen for the echo of your
footsteps" speech to the president. I found myself thinking
about a movie I used to love as a little girl (in a rather
complicated fashion cause it also really upset me) called The
Blue Bird. I only recently found out that one of the
spirit children is supposed to be President Lincoln.
Every time I watch this I mean to look up where that "they also
serve who stand and wait" quote comes from and this time I
actually did. It's from a John Milton poem.
If I had to teach a person what I believed about free will, I
think I'd show them this episode. I love how Sam speaks
about it at the bar the night of the assassination.
I still jump when you hear the shot. And it's Pavlovian...
right when John walks onto the screen in that scene my eyes well
up because I hate seeing him flinch like that... and knowing why,
Goosebumps again when Monica wipes away that soldier's tear.
Although I think the "Battle Hymn" has a lot to do with it.
He looks so impossibly young all of a sudden when JWB
dies... I just wanna hug him. And I love how I just
use "he" all the time now cause everyone MUST know who I mean!
"A heart can change in an instant and each heart must be given
that chance." Another good one from Sam.
"God can make a hero out of you if you let Him." I love that
quote from Tess.
I've never thought about it much before but I love that Tess tells
Calvin to tell President Lincoln his dream. I'm a big
believer in talking to our dearly departed.
the Episode Guide
photographs used on this page are from "Touched by an Angel" and
owned by CBS Productions, Caroline Productions, and Moon Water
Productions. They are not being used to seek profit.)